Whole Home Backup vs. Partial Home Backup: Which Power Solution is Right for You?

When it comes to backup power solutions whether it’s solar + battery storage, a generator, or a hybrid system choosing between whole home backup and partial home backup depends on how much of your home you want to power during an outage. Your decision will be influenced by factors like budget, power needs, and the level of comfort you expect when the grid goes down.

What’s the Difference?

Whole Home Backup

What It Is:

A whole home backup system ensures that all electrical loads in your home continue running during a power outage. This is typically achieved by installing a Microgrid Interconnect Device (MID) between the electric meter and the Main Service Panel (MSP). The MID redirects power from the grid to the backup system, supporting the entire MSP.

In homes with an All-In-One Panel (where the meter, main breaker, and load breakers are in one unit), all circuits must be transferred into a new dedicated Backup Load Panel. Unlike partial home backup systems that only support selected circuits, whole home backup ensures no load is left unpowered.

Why It’s Great:

• Comprehensive coverage: Everything in your house remains operational.

• Convenience: No need to manually switch circuits or appliances on and off.

• Full home continuity: Your HVAC system, entertainment setup, and all appliances continue running.

• Increased property value: Homes with backup power are attractive to buyers, especially in areas prone to outages.

• Scalability: You can expand your backup system over time with additional battery storage.

Why It Might Not Be Right for You:

• Higher cost: Installation and maintenance are expensive due to the need for larger batteries and a bigger inverter.

• Larger energy storage requirements: Keeping everything powered for days requires substantial (and costly) storage capacity.

• More maintenance: A bigger system means more components to monitor, including batteries and inverters.

Partial Home Backup

What It Is:

A partial home backup system powers only selected circuits during an outage instead of the entire home. This setup involves installing a Backup Load Panel (BLP), which moves essential circuits from the Main Service Panel (MSP) to the backup system.

Typically, a partial backup system prioritizes critical loads such as:

• Refrigerator

• Microwave

• Lighting

• Critical outlets

• Furnace blower (for gas heating systems)

The system is usually powered by a smaller generator or battery-based inverter, configured to support only these essential loads.

Why It’s Great:

• Lower cost: Since it powers fewer circuits, installation and maintenance costs are lower.

• Simpler installation: Fewer circuits mean an easier and quicker setup.

• Flexibility: Choose which systems or appliances are most important to keep running.

• Smaller storage needs: Requires less battery storage or a smaller generator, saving space and money.

• Efficiency: More effective for short-term outages since it focuses on essential devices.

Why It Might Not Be Right for You:

• Limited power: Only selected appliances stay on, so you may lack full comfort during an outage.

• Manual switching: Some setups require manual control of power distribution, though Automatic Transfer Switches (ATS) can help.

• Load management: You may need to decide between running different appliances simultaneously (e.g., fridge vs. water heater).

Which One is Right for You?

Whole Home Backup is a Good Choice If:

• You want full comfort and convenience with no compromises during outages.

• Your home has high power needs, such as running medical equipment, multiple fridges, or HVAC systems.

• You live in an area with frequent or long-lasting power outages.

• You’re looking for a long-term investment that increases property value.

Partial Home Backup Might Be Better If:

• You only need to keep essential devices running, such as the fridge, lights, and a few appliances.

• You have a tighter budget and are willing to sacrifice some comfort during an outage.

• You live in an area where outages are rare or brief.

• You prefer a simpler, more affordable solution.

Ultimately, the choice between whole home and partial home backup depends on your power requirements, budget, and the level of comfort you expect when the lights go out. No matter which option you choose, both provide peace of mind by ensuring your home remains powered when the grid fails. Still not sure what is the best choice for you? seek help from an experienced consultant who can analyze your needs and provide a tailored solution.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What is solar curtailment in Australia?

Solar curtailment occurs when generators are required to reduce output due to grid constraints, despite available solar resource. In the National Electricity Market, this is typically driven by congestion, voltage limits, and system security requirements set by Australian Energy Market Operator.

2. Why is solar curtailment increasing in the NEM?

Renewable capacity is growing faster than transmission infrastructure. Many regional networks were designed to serve demand, not export generation, creating bottlenecks as new solar connects.

3. Can battery storage reduce solar curtailment?

Yes, but only when properly designed. Co-located BESS can reduce curtailment by absorbing excess generation and reshaping exports, provided it is engineered around local network constraints rather than generic assumptions.

4. What is Hybrid Energy Yield Assessment (Hybrid EYA)?

Hybrid EYA models solar, battery storage, load, and grid constraints as a single integrated system. It captures real-time interactions that conventional, sequential energy modelling misses.

5. Which regions in Australia experience the highest curtailment?

Curtailment is most severe in constrained regional zones, particularly western New South Wales, north-west Victoria, and parts of South Australia, where congestion and voltage limits are already binding.

6. How can battery charging contribute to curtailment?

During peak solar periods, high battery charging can increase local voltage, reducing allowable export capacity. If the battery fills too early, it may be unavailable when curtailment risk is highest.

7. What is the difference between structural and recoverable curtailment?

Structural curtailment is driven by persistent transmission limits and requires network upgrades. Recoverable curtailment arises from operational constraints and can often be mitigated through storage design and control strategy.

8. How accurate is Hybrid EYA compared to traditional modelling?

Hybrid EYA provides materially higher accuracy in constrained networks by explicitly modelling voltage limits, export constraints, and battery state-of-charge dynamics that standard yield assessments ignore.

9. When should Hybrid EYA be used?

Hybrid EYA is essential when export limits are below peak generation, networks are voltage-constrained, or battery sizing and control materially affect curtailment and revenue.

10. Will transmission upgrades eliminate curtailment in Australia?

Transmission upgrades will help in the medium term, but they won’t arrive fast enough for projects being developed today. Curtailment risk must be managed through intelligent system design in the interim.